Tell a smaller story
The idea
When you want people to act, tell a short, true story with most of the detail left out, so they have room to put themselves in it.
Where it comes from
Stephen Denning’s article “Telling Tales” (Harvard Business Review, May 2004), reprinted in HBR’s 10 Must Reads on Communication. Denning ran knowledge management at the World Bank and wrote The Springboard about what he learned there.
The story
In 1996 Stephen Denning was a manager at the World Bank with an idea nobody wanted. The Bank saw itself as a lender. Denning thought its real asset was what its people knew about fighting poverty, and that this knowledge should be organised and shared with anyone who needed it. He made the case the way most of us would. He built charts, he laid out the reasons, and he presented them. His colleagues listened politely and went back to work.
Out of options, he tried something else. He told them about a health worker in a tiny town in Zambia, about 600 km from the capital. In June 1995 this person needed to know how to treat malaria, logged on to the website of the Centers for Disease Control in Atlanta, and found the answer. Then Denning pointed out what was missing from the picture. The World Bank was not in it. One of the largest stores of development know-how in the world, and a health worker in rural Zambia could not get at any of it.
That was the whole story. It took well under a minute to tell. And it did what the charts had not. People in the room started asking why the Bank could not do this, and what it would take. Later that year knowledge sharing became official strategy, and by 2000 the Bank was being benchmarked as a world leader in the field.
The interesting part is what Denning learned next. He went to find out why the story had worked, and the professional storytellers he met were unimpressed. By their standards it barely counted as a story. There was no character to care about, no build-up, no texture. We never learn the health worker’s name. A proper telling would describe the heat, the clinic, the patient waiting, the slow connection.
Denning’s conclusion was that for this job the experts had it backwards. His warning in the article is blunt: “Beware the well-told story!” A richly told tale pulls the audience into the storyteller’s world. They are in Zambia, with that health worker, enjoying it. A sparse one leaves them free to wander, and where they wander is their own work. The Bank’s staff had all been asked questions in the field that they could not answer. Given a thin sketch, each of them filled it in from their own experience and arrived at the conclusion themselves. An idea you reach on your own is one you will defend.
He called these springboard stories, and the recipe is short. It must be true. It should be about one person, in a situation the audience recognises. It should show a change that has already worked somewhere. And it should be told with as little detail as you can get away with. Denning is careful to say this is one tool for one job. If you want to pass on values or show people who you are, a fuller story is right. But when the task is moving sceptical people to act, small beats polished.
A question to sit with
What is the one-minute true story that would make your case better than your next slide deck?