Safe is a bet too
The idea
The choice that feels safe often carries the bigger risk, because it caps your upside. The choice that feels risky often caps your downside and buys you options.
Where it comes from
Erik Torenberg, “Take Asymmetric Bets”.
The story
Torenberg says we get risk backwards. We think starting a company is risky, when it actually buys optionality. We think joining Goldman Sachs buys optionality, when it is actually a big risk. Starting the company caps your downside. Joining the bank caps your upside.
His test is simple. Founding a company has job risk, but little career risk. If it works, the upside is enormous. If it fails, you still leave with more options than you came in with. That is an asymmetric bet: small, survivable losses against a large possible win.
He adds a catch most people skip: “assuming the privilege to afford it.” The downside is only capped if you can survive it. Taleb puts it more bluntly. You can love risk and still be completely averse to ruin. Edward Thorp, who made a career of betting with an edge, says it is the dosage that matters. Not too little, not too much.
Then Torenberg makes his sharpest point. The bigger risk is not that you fail. It is that you take too few shots to ever hit the big one. James Clear says the same thing: the person who gets one shot needs everything to go right. The person who gets a thousand will score at some point.
So the real danger is not the bet. It is the single, oversized bet, or no bet at all.
More on risk
- “Most people think they’re risk-neutral, but in reality, they’re still far too risk averse… You can almost always recover and turn things back on.” Daniel Frank, Daniel-isms
- “Whenever I have the choice of doing something with an uncertain but potentially high upside, I try to do it.” Guy Spier, The Education of a Value Investor
- “Not taking risks leads to regrets which ages you faster.” Tim Denning
- “Not all risk takers are winners, but all winners are risk takers.” Yash Tekriwal
- “People vastly overestimate the consequences of failure today.” Michael Easter, The Comfort Crisis
- “There is no adventure without risk.” Yvon Chouinard
- “Don’t cap your ceiling.” Erik Torenberg
A question to sit with
Which choice in your life feels safe only because you have never priced the upside it caps?