Forward Trajectory
Building and scaling companies 3 min read

Let the closest person decide

The idea

The person nearest the customer usually knows something head office does not. Give them the authority to act on it.

Where it comes from

Ray Kroc, who built McDonald’s, in his memoir Grinding It Out (1977). I highlighted the line when I read the book in 2021.

The story

Kroc was 52 and selling milkshake mixers when he walked into the McDonald brothers’ hamburger stand in San Bernardino in 1954. What he built from it is famous for sameness. A burger in one town had to match the burger in the next, and Kroc was strict about it.

So it is easy to assume he ran everything from the centre. On decisions he did the opposite. “It has always been my belief that authority should be placed at the lowest possible level,” he wrote. He wanted the person closest to the stores to make the call without waiting for a directive from headquarters. In 1965 he split the company into regional offices and handed them many of head office’s powers.

The best evidence that he was right is the menu.

In 1962 Lou Groen had a struggling McDonald’s in a heavily Catholic part of Cincinnati. His customers did not eat meat on Fridays, so on Fridays they ate somewhere else. Groen came up with a fried fish sandwich and took it to Kroc, who hated the idea. He did not want his stores smelling of fish, and he had a meatless invention of his own, the Hula Burger: a slice of pineapple and cheese on a bun. They agreed to sell both on the same Friday and let the till decide. By the usual account Groen sold 350 fish sandwiches and the pineapple sold six. The Filet-O-Fish went onto the national menu in 1965.

Jim Delligatti, a franchisee near Pittsburgh, spent two years asking the company for a bigger burger and was turned down each time. When he was finally allowed to try, he was told to use only ingredients already in the store. He bent that rule to get a three-part bun, and on 22 April 1967 he put the Big Mac on sale in Uniontown, Pennsylvania, for 45 cents. It went national the following year.

Herb Peterson, an operator in Santa Barbara, built the Egg McMuffin in 1971. It was in test markets by 1972 and across the country by 1975.

Those are three of the best-known products in the company’s history, and none of them came from head office. Each came from an operator who could see something in his own store that nobody at headquarters could.

Look at what Kroc handed over and what he kept. He never let go of the standard. The burger still had to be the same everywhere. What he pushed down was the judgement about what the customer in front of you needs. And when he disagreed, as he did with Groen, he did not pull rank. He ran a test and accepted the result, even though his own sandwich was the one that lost.

That last part is the hard bit. Saying “you decide” is easy when you agree with the decision. Kroc thought the fish sandwich was a bad idea and it went on the menu anyway.

A question to sit with

Which decision are you still making at the centre that someone closer to the customer could make better?

Created with the help of AI.

Related ideas

Follow along

Want to keep up with what I am building and thinking about?

LinkedIn is where I am easiest to find. Follow me there, and say hello.

Follow Craig on LinkedIn