Forward Trajectory
Decisions and judgement 3 min read

Judge the decision, not the result

The idea

A good result doesn’t prove the decision was good, and a bad result doesn’t prove it was bad. Judge a decision by what you knew when you made it.

Where it comes from

Fooled by Randomness (2001) by Nassim Nicholas Taleb, a former options trader who watched lucky people get mistaken for skilled ones.

The story

Taleb asks you to imagine a bored, eccentric tycoon who offers you $10 million to play Russian roulette. One bullet, six chambers, one pull of the trigger against your own head.

Five times out of six you walk away rich. One time in six you don’t walk away at all.

Suppose you play and win. You have $10 million in the bank, and the people around you admire you as a bold risk taker. Taleb’s point is that this is not the same $10 million a dentist earns over a career of careful work, even though the bank statements look identical. One of you made a sound decision. The other made a terrible one and got away with it.

Nobody can see the difference, because we only ever see the one history that happened. Taleb calls the rest alternative histories: all the ways it could have gone and didn’t. He adds that a 25-year-old who played once a year would be very unlikely to reach 50. But if thousands of people played, you would end up with a handful of very rich survivors and a large cemetery. The survivors are the ones we would hear from.

Real life is harder than the thought experiment, because the gun is hidden. Taleb says reality’s revolver has hundreds of chambers, not six. After a few dozen pulls with no bang, you forget there is a bullet at all, and you start calling it skill.

The trap works in both directions. We copy the bold calls of people who won, without asking how many others made the same call and vanished. And we punish sound decisions that went wrong, in ourselves and in our teams, until nobody is willing to make a reasonable bet. Taleb’s rule is that a mistake should be judged in the light of the information available at the time, not after the fact. As he puts it: “Heroes are heroes because they are heroic in behavior, not because they won or lost.”

He also notices something uncomfortable about how we use this idea. Nobody accepts randomness in his own success, only in his failure. We say “the decision was right, the outcome was unlucky” when we lose. We almost never say “the decision was poor, I was lucky” when we win.

There is a practical version of all this. Before a big call, write down what you know, what you expect and why. When the result comes in, read the note before you read the scoreboard. And check one more thing Taleb insists on: it doesn’t matter how often a bet pays off if the one time it fails is too costly to bear.

A question to sit with

Which of your recent wins would you not repeat if you could see all six chambers?

Created with the help of AI.

Related ideas

Follow along

Want to keep up with what I am building and thinking about?

LinkedIn is where I am easiest to find. Follow me there, and say hello.

Follow Craig on LinkedIn