Forward Trajectory
Leadership and culture 2 min read

Trust people before they've earned it

The idea

Most of us wait for people to earn our trust. That is backwards. Trust is what lets them earn it, so give it first.

Where it comes from

George Shultz, US Secretary of Labor, Treasury and State, writing in December 2020 as he turned 100. And Henry Stimson, US Secretary of War, in a memo to President Truman in September 1945, quoted in Eric Schlosser’s Command and Control.

The story

Looking back on a century, Shultz said the one lesson he kept relearning was this: “When trust was in the room, whatever room that was… good things happened. When trust was not in the room, good things did not happen. Everything else is details.”

So how does trust get into the room? Most of us wait. We watch the new hire or the new partner and hand out trust in small amounts as they prove themselves.

Stimson thought that was backwards. A month after Hiroshima, he argued that keeping the bomb secret, with the weapon “rather ostentatiously on our hip”, would only feed Soviet suspicion and start an arms race. Then he wrote down the chief lesson of his long life:

“The only way you can make a man trustworthy is to trust him; and the surest way to make him untrustworthy is to distrust him and show your distrust.”

Truman did not take the advice. The arms race came anyway.

In a company, distrust is visible. People notice when every decision needs sign-off and their work is checked twice. They stop taking ownership, because it was never offered. Then the manager points to the lack of ownership as proof the distrust was right.

Hand someone a real decision and they usually rise to it. Sometimes you will be let down. That costs far less than a team that has learned it isn’t trusted. Someone has to go first. It is usually cheaper if it is you.

A question to sit with

Who on your team are you still waiting on to prove themselves, and what would change if you trusted them first?

Created with the help of AI.

Related ideas

Follow along

Want to keep up with what I am building and thinking about?

LinkedIn is where I am easiest to find. Follow me there, and say hello.

Follow Craig on LinkedIn