Forward Trajectory
Decisions and judgement 4 min read

It is not a verdict

The idea

Most of what feels like a judgement on you is really information about where the other person is standing. Read it that way and you decide better.

Where it comes from

This week’s four posts. Ben Horowitz in The Hard Thing About Hard Things. Sahil Bloom’s essay “The Frog Pond Effect”, with the research of James A. Davis and of Pauline Clance and Suzanne Imes underneath it. Deborah Tannen’s “The Power of Talk” from Harvard Business Review. And Harry Beckwith’s Selling the Invisible.

The story

Start with Monday. In the spring of 2000 the Nasdaq was falling and Ben Horowitz was trying to raise $120 million for Loudcloud. Most of the investors he pitched said no. A few months earlier the company had been the hottest name in Silicon Valley, so every no felt like a ruling on the business. It was nothing of the sort. Each one was a single fund, with its own timing and its own appetite for risk that month. Horowitz kept going, closed the round in June, and took a rule from it: “Look for a market of one.” The investors who passed did not get a vote.

On Tuesday the same mistake showed up pointing inwards. James A. Davis found in 1966 that capable students at the best American colleges saw themselves as average, because marks rank you against the people sitting next to you. They trimmed their ambitions to match. The feeling was real. It measured the pond and told them nothing about the frog. Clance and Imes found the same thing a decade later in more than 150 high-achieving women who were privately sure they had fooled everyone.

On Wednesday it was a mistake we make about other people. Deborah Tannen describes a chief executive who approved a proposal if the presenter seemed confident and turned it down if not. She also describes Sally, who was known as outgoing in Texas and written off as shy in Washington, because the pauses in a Washington meeting were too short for her to speak into. Sally was the same person in both cities. Her boss had taken a habit of speech for a measure of ability.

And on Thursday it was the buyer. Harry Beckwith’s point is that a buyer is rarely ranking the options to find the best one. They are worried, and they are looking for the choice least likely to go wrong. Williams and Miller found that the largest group of executives, 36% of the 1,684 they studied, decide by following what has already worked for someone they trust. So when a big company hesitates over something new, the hesitation says very little about the product. It says a great deal about what happens to the person who signs if it fails.

Put the four side by side. A no, a doubt, a quiet voice and a hesitation. Each one arrives feeling like a measurement of quality. Each is mostly a measurement of position: where the fund is in its cycle, how big your pond has become, where the speaker grew up, how exposed the buyer is.

Two of them are about how we read ourselves, and two are about how we read others. That is why it is worth seeing them together. The founder who takes a no as a verdict on the business is making the same error as the chief executive who takes a hesitant presenter as a verdict on the work.

The fix was the same every time too. Stop reading the room and go and get evidence that does not depend on it. Horowitz kept pitching until he found the one. Clance and Imes put people in a room to say the feeling out loud, and they discovered everyone else had it. Tannen says to check the work and not the delivery. Beckwith offers a small trial, so the buyer has proof in place of a promise. In each case the question changes from “what does this say about me?” to “what is this person dealing with?”

A question to sit with

Which signal are you treating as a verdict this week, and what would you find if you went and checked?

Created with the help of AI.

Related ideas

Follow along

Want to keep up with what I am building and thinking about?

LinkedIn is where I am easiest to find. Follow me there, and say hello.

Follow Craig on LinkedIn