Forward Trajectory
Decisions and judgement 4 min read

Hold a few things tightly

The idea

Pick the very few things you will not bend on, hold them hard, and deliberately let go of the rest. Most of what you let go was never yours to control anyway.

Where it comes from

This week’s four posts. Ray Kroc in Grinding It Out. Yvon Chouinard, in Jimmy Chin’s profile of him. Stephen Denning’s “Telling Tales” from Harvard Business Review. And Nassim Nicholas Taleb’s Fooled by Randomness.

The story

Start with Monday. Ray Kroc built McDonald’s on sameness. A burger in one town had to match the burger in the next, and he was strict about it. You would expect a man like that to be strict about everything. He wasn’t. In 1962 Lou Groen, a franchisee in Cincinnati, wanted to sell a fried fish sandwich to his Catholic customers on Fridays. Kroc hated the idea and had a meatless sandwich of his own, a slice of pineapple and cheese on a bun. He could have pulled rank. He let both go on sale on the same Friday, and by the usual account the fish outsold the pineapple by 350 to six. The Filet-O-Fish went national in 1965. Kroc held the standard and gave away the decision.

On Tuesday it was Yvon Chouinard. By 1970 his company was the largest supplier of climbing hardware in the United States, and its steel pitons were damaging the rock his customers loved. What he would not bend on was the intent: make the best climbing gear without wrecking the rock. So he let go of the product the company had been built on. The 1972 catalogue opened by asking climbers to stop using pitons, and carried a 14-page essay on climbing with aluminium chocks. Within months the piton business had withered and the chocks were selling faster than the company could make them. Decades later he gave Jimmy Chin the rule: “So you don’t focus on profit. You focus on intent.”

On Wednesday the thing being let go was detail. In 1996 Stephen Denning could not get the World Bank to care about sharing what it knew. His charts had failed. What worked was a story that took under a minute, about a health worker in a small town in Zambia who found out how to treat malaria on the website of the Centers for Disease Control in Atlanta. We never learn the health worker’s name. Denning kept the story true and kept its point. Everything else he left out, so each listener filled the gaps from their own work and reached the conclusion themselves.

And on Thursday it was the result. Taleb’s tycoon offers you $10 million to play Russian roulette. If you win, your bank statement looks the same as that of someone who earned the money carefully, and nobody can see the difference. Taleb’s rule is to judge a decision by the information available when it was made. You hold yourself to the quality of the decision. The outcome has luck in it, and luck does not take instructions.

Put the four side by side. Each of them was strict about one thing and relaxed about something most of us cling to. Kroc fixed the standard and released the decisions. Chouinard fixed the intent and released the product. Denning fixed the truth of the story and released the telling. Taleb fixes the decision and releases the result.

Now look at what was released. What a customer in a Cincinnati store wants on a Friday. What climbers will buy next year. The picture that forms in a listener’s head. Which chamber the bullet is in. None of these was ever under anyone’s control. Gripping them only makes you slow, and it takes your attention off the things you really can hold.

It also runs the other way. The freedom only worked because something was fixed. Kroc’s franchisees could invent because the standard was not up for discussion. Chouinard could drop his main product because everyone, customers included, knew what the company was for.

There is a price. You find out whether you mean it on the day it costs you something. Kroc’s own sandwich lost, in public, and the fish went on the menu. Chouinard’s best seller went out of the catalogue.

A question to sit with

What are the two or three things you will not bend on, and what are you still gripping that was never yours to control?

Created with the help of AI.

Related ideas

Follow along

Want to keep up with what I am building and thinking about?

LinkedIn is where I am easiest to find. Follow me there, and say hello.

Follow Craig on LinkedIn