Get the intent right
The idea
Profit is what you get when you do the right things well. Lead with what the business is for, and keep profit as the score.
Where it comes from
Yvon Chouinard, the climber who founded Patagonia, in a profile written by the climber and film-maker Jimmy Chin. I highlighted it when I read it.
The story
In 1957 Yvon Chouinard was a young climber in California who wanted better pitons, the steel spikes climbers hammer into cracks in the rock. He bought a used coal-fired forge and an anvil from a junkyard, taught himself blacksmithing and set up in his parents’ backyard in Burbank. He could make two pitons an hour and sold them for $1.50 each.
By 1970 Chouinard Equipment was the largest supplier of climbing hardware in the United States. By the company’s own account it had also become a villain. His pitons were hard steel, made to be hammered in and pulled out again, and the rock that climbers loved was being damaged by the gear he sold them.
So Chouinard and his partner, Tom Frost, decided to wind down the piton business. This was the product the company had been built on. They had an alternative, aluminium chocks that a climber wedges into a crack by hand and lifts out again, but nobody knew whether climbers would trust them.
They did not hedge. The first Chouinard Equipment catalogue, in 1972, opened by asking customers to stop using pitons. It carried a 14-page essay by a Sierra climber, Doug Robinson, on how to climb with chocks instead. Think about that for a moment. The market leader used its own catalogue to talk its customers out of its main product.
Within a few months the piton business had withered, and the chocks were selling faster than the company could make them.
Decades later Chouinard explained the thinking to Jimmy Chin. He has studied Zen for much of his life, and what it taught him is that if you do everything the right way, the profits come. “So you don’t focus on profit. You focus on intent,” he said. He applies the same rule to climbing and to cooking. His point is that a simple, clear intent forces you to be creative, because the easy options are no longer open to you.
The piton decision is that rule in practice. The intent was simple: make the best climbing gear without wrecking the rock. Pitons failed that test, so the question stopped being “how do we protect our sales?” and became “what do we make instead?” The answer turned out to be a better business.
He kept going in the same direction. In September 2022, aged 83, he and his family gave Patagonia away. The voting shares went to a trust that guards the company’s purpose. The other 98% went to a non-profit that spends the profits on protecting the environment, reported at the time as about $100 million a year from a company valued at about $3 billion.
What strikes me is what this does for everyone else in the business. Most people in a company never see the income statement, and they cannot steer by it. They can all steer by a clear intent. In 1972 every person at Chouinard Equipment, and every customer, knew exactly what the company stood for.
A question to sit with
If your team could not see the numbers, would they still know what you are trying to do?